A gas distributor took me on a tour of their facility and showed me where they keep their good liquid cylinders and where they keep those needing repair. On a side of their yard was a third group of about two dozen liquid cylinders that I pointed out and was told they were scraps. When asked if they were inner leakers or otherwise beyond repair the client said essentially "Oh, no. They are just those cruddy old liquid-only vessels. No one uses them anymore."
Another distributor took over the business at a very large mixed use facility with a number of labs using nitrogen liquid. Scattered about the labs was a large number of liquid-only style liquid cylinders. The client was told that instead of liquid-only vessels they would be getting "the good stuff" all through their plant...... meaning VGLs.
Both cases share a pretty common perception and contributed to a belief among some users that vendors are somehow denying them top quality when they provide Liquid-Only liquid cylinders for applications where the only need is for nitrogen in a liquid form.
A counterpoint to this perception is the fact that liquid-only style 4L-DOT liquid cylinders will contain nitrogen in a liquid state longer than a same sized liquid cylinder with Gas Use capabilities.
Why?
Absent the gas use function, Liquid-Only liquid cylinders do not have Gas Use Vaporization Coils, Pressure Building Coils, Regulators and other heat syncs that transmit energy (heat) into the liquid and cause it to boil off more quickly.
The funny thing is that the myth of Liquid-Only vessels being "cruddy" is so pervasive that a large percentage of people are unaware you can even still buy Liquid-Only containers. And even those that do know you can are reluctant to get them due to backlash they often get from users who feel they are somehow being short-shrifted.
Paradigm shift?
Showing posts with label VGL. Show all posts
Showing posts with label VGL. Show all posts
Friday, August 7, 2009
Thursday, June 4, 2009
A Better Fix for Less?
Possibility: End users have been cranking down on the pressure builders of his liquid cylinders to try and get more flow out of them.
The rub is that the flow from a DOT 4L-200 or a 4L-292 is just almost identical (+/- 300scfh depending on the model and whether you are vaporizing liquid oxygen, nitrogen or argon). So, higher pressure will not make higher flow. What will provide extra flow is to add some downstream vaporization allowing for a doubling or more of the gas withdrawal rate.
Suggestion: Put a hang-on Vap on the liquid cylinder at a cost of around $1000 to $2000. This is:
a) a lot less expensive than purchasing six new higher pressure liquid cylinders at $2000 to $3000 each;
b) actually better since it solves the problem which the new liquid cylinders would not;
c) and keeps the existing liquid cylinders in service and generating revenue.
Granted- this is assuming that the real issue is flow. We discussed visiting with the customer first to get a better idea of their application. There are just so many more applications that run at 80 to 110psi versus over 200psi means that it is likely they really don’t need 350psi liquid cylinders.
Pay a lot less and get what you really need? Hmmm.........
Saturday, March 21, 2009
Cryogenic Liquid Cylinders- Safe Lifting Method

A few weeks ago we discussed some of the potential hazards and risks associated with lifting liquid cylinders to elevated locations along with ways not to lift them. It is agreed among all manufacturers that the handling ring around the top of a liquid cylinder is not to be used as a lifting point. While some instruction manuals show cryogenic liquid cylinders being lifted by the holes in the handling ring support brackets this is not a universally recommended practice. This is especially true regarding full cylinders being lifted overhead. The risk of lifting any liquid argon, oxygen or nitrogen vgls by the support brackets are that:
a) It is unlikely if you know the specific cylinder you are lifting is one with supports designed for lifting;
b) The liquid cylinder supports could have been weakened over time by being bent and straightened or through metal fatigue or corrosion.
In any case- the support brackets can tear away from the vessel allowing it to drop. A liquid cylinder full of product that is dropped from an overhead location is a clear hazard.
So- What are the options?
1) Consider running feed lines up from your vessel to the work area first and keeping all liquid containers at ground level;
2) If the distance from the ground to a work area is prohibitively long then use a safe carrier to raise the vessel to the area needed.
A photograph of an enclosed carrier for lifting liquid cylinders is shown. These can also be fitted with lifting eyes on all four corners for 4-point lifting. Be sure that whatever you use that the device is regularly inspected for damage or corrosion and that any lifting cables are in-spec for the intended purpose.
a) It is unlikely if you know the specific cylinder you are lifting is one with supports designed for lifting;
b) The liquid cylinder supports could have been weakened over time by being bent and straightened or through metal fatigue or corrosion.
In any case- the support brackets can tear away from the vessel allowing it to drop. A liquid cylinder full of product that is dropped from an overhead location is a clear hazard.
So- What are the options?
1) Consider running feed lines up from your vessel to the work area first and keeping all liquid containers at ground level;
2) If the distance from the ground to a work area is prohibitively long then use a safe carrier to raise the vessel to the area needed.
A photograph of an enclosed carrier for lifting liquid cylinders is shown. These can also be fitted with lifting eyes on all four corners for 4-point lifting. Be sure that whatever you use that the device is regularly inspected for damage or corrosion and that any lifting cables are in-spec for the intended purpose.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)