Showing posts with label relief. Show all posts
Showing posts with label relief. Show all posts

Monday, March 2, 2009

"Fixed"- What's in a word?

It is said that a key to gaining knowledge is learning the right words. Working with cryogenic tanks has proven a challenge mostly due to the English language and the use of multiple words for a single item as well as the use of a single word for many items.

For example, a client might call asking for “a Safety.” Seems easy, right?

So, you sent them a “Safety.” Did you send them a relief, a burst disk, a rupture disk, a head safety, or a vacuum rupture disk? Was it an in-line device or open to atmosphere? What pressure was it set at and how did you know the right pressure? Did you simply look at the pressure of the device being replaced and put on the same thing?

I ask because a client called one day and somewhat urgently wanted to know if we could replace one of the safeties on their truck mounted liquid oxygen delivery vessel right away. Their safety was apparently “broken” and the vessel wasn’t holding pressure so they couldn’t do their medical oxygen deliveries. It was close to closing time and they were several hours away so we gave them an after-hours number to call when they got to the shop so we could meet them. Paraphrasing Jimmy Buffet, the phone never rang so we knew it was them.

Several days later the wayward van arrived with the driver all calm and composed. When asked how they survived without the safety being repaired the driver responded:

“Oh, we’ve been OK. It turns out that one of the guys in the shop has a lot of cryogenics experience and he ‘fixed’ it.” This gave rise to that little sick feeling that the wrong words can generate. Predictably, the “experienced” guy in the shop had removed a blown burst disk safety and installed plug in its place to “fix” it.

See the post dated 1/19/09 if you’d like a better idea of what this “fix” might have meant to the driver. http://cryonews.blogspot.com/2009/01/improperly-decommissioned-liquid.html


Friday, February 20, 2009

Faster Liquid Nitrogen Flow


A university lab called today with a very similar question to one received earlier in the week. Again, they have a cryogenic liquid nitrogen cylinder that is set up for liquid only. This means that the only valve connections are “Liquid” and “Vent.” As was the case with a previous caller, they needed more pressure to push liquid out faster. Their proposed solution was to feed high pressure gas into the vent side forcing a high liquid discharge flow.

Did I have a problem with this? Yes.

And what was the problem? The problem is the fact that the high pressure gas cylinder was starting out with 1000psi or so of pressure and they were going to depend on manual control of a valve to regulate how much pressure they were putting into a DOT 4L-100 liquid cylinder fitted with a 150-175 psi burst disk and 22 psi relief. Granted, the relief should open if pressure gets too high and if the flow is not high enough from the relief then the burst disk would blow. The problem is that the combined outlet flow from both could possibly be too low to fully relieve the pressure coming in from the gas cylinder. This could ultimately result in the vessel exploding.

It was strongly suggested that they avoid this non-standard operation and instead secure a VGL with a pressure building circuit so that the vessel could be operated as designed. There is just no justification for generating a risk and possibly hurting someone by jury-rigging a container.